Breaking Software Protection: ElGamal Signature Scheme
In today’s article, we will see a more advanced cryptosystem than the previous one: the ElGamal Signature scheme (not to be confused with ElGamal Encryption). So before you start reading this, read the first article for more details.
- The target file (CryptoChallenge2.exe)
- ELGAMALSiGNiT: An ElGamal signature scheme tool (requires dotNetFx4)
- IDA (Interactive Disassembler)
- RE-SIGS: IDA signature
- GODUP: OllyDBG plugin
- DLP Tool
What is ElGamal?
ElGamal is a public-key cryptosystem developed by Taher Elgamal in 1985. It has two variants: Encryption and Digital Signatures (which we’ll learn today). Its strength lies in the difficulty of calculating discrete logarithms (DLP Problem).
- Choose a key length (measured in bits).
- Generate a random prime number P.
- Generate two random numbers, generator G and Private key X, with (G<P and X<P).
- Calculate Y=G^X mod P.
- Public keys are: (P, G and Y), Private key is X.
To sign a message (M) (where M < P), one would:
- Generate a random number K where (K<P-1).
R=G^K (mod p)
S=(H(M)-RX)*K^(-1) (mod p-1)
The signature will be the pair C(R,S).
To verify a given pair C(R,S), we would compute:
V1=G^M (mod p)
V2=Y^R * R^S (mod p)
For an example, we will use the ELGAMALSiGNiT Tool which is an automation of all of the above. The tool is very easy to use in just a few steps:
- Choose a key size from 16 to 1024.
- Click ‘GENERATE KEYS (P,G,X) to get the prime (P), generator (G) and private keys (X).
- Click ‘CALCULATE Y=G^X (MOD P)’ to compute Y.
- Check the output mode of M: (HEX, MD5 or SHA256).
- Type something in ‘M’, you’ll see H(M) changing while you’re typing.
- To generate a random K click ‘GENERATE’ (remember to click ‘GENERATE’ every time you want a new signature).
- To Sign a message, click ‘Sign’.
- To verify C(R,S) click ‘Verify’.
You can see the result in the following picture:
In every challenge (Keygenme), or at least those that I’ve seen, they use the verification formulas to check the serial(s) in the same way as what we are going to see here.
I will assume you’ve read the first article and know or have done these steps: target analyses in PEiD, crypto signatures extraction from IDA, and importing signatures into OllyDbg using GODUP. I’ll jump straight to the debugging process.
Set a breakpoint on 00401189 (F2) (serial verification algorithm) and press F9. The target will run, enter any name (between 3 and 15 characters) and a serial (that has exactly 64 characters). Click ‘Check’ if everything is good, and the debugger will break at that address. Keep tracing (F8).
The target first gets the size of our name, puts it in EBX, and then generates an md5 hash for our name and converts it to hexadecimal. The result is put in 0x408063.
Here is an algo that divides our serial into two parts of 33 chars (PUSH 21). The 1st part is put in 0x407863 and the 2nd in 0x407C63. Similar to lstrcpyn.
Here we see a lot of _BigCreate (I assume you already know what it does from the first article).
In the above picture we can see the calls to _BigIn. We can see a lot of numbers are divided serials and md5. The rest are for ElGamal’s verification.
To make things a little clearer:
- 0x407863 = 11111111111111111111111111111111 (Serial1) = 0x408818 (Address of serial1 in big integer)
- 0x407C63 = 11111111111111111111111111111111 (Serial2) = 0x40881C
- 0x408063 = 4D945493477571DE563E281CA4145EB9 (MD5Hash) = 0x408808
- 0x407000 = 8D11C0544299C92AB3A2B2DF361DFB97 (BigNum1) = 0x40880C
- 0x407021 = 3D87547CD25B3F8703CCFBB81ACB4423 (BigNum2) = 0x408810
- 0x407042 = 120820939A56802A8558641177EAB1CA (BigNum3) = 0x408814
Let’s make our variables from the above:
- R = 0x408818
- S = 0x40881C
- M = 0x408808
- X = 0x40880C
- Y = 0x408810
- Z = 0x408814
That is what really interests us.
- At address 0x4012CF there is a call to _BigMod used as follows: M = M mod X. This is used to check if M < X (which is P).
- At 0x4012EC a call to _BigPowMod which is used as: 0x408820 = Y^M mod X
- At 0x401309 another call to _BigPowMod: 0x408824 = Z^R mod X
- A third call to _BigPowMod at 0x401326 : 0x408828 = R^S mod
- At 0x401343 a call to _BigMulMod : 0x40882C = 0x408824 * 0x408828 mod X
- At 0x401354 a call to _BigCompare, which compares 0x408820 with 0x40882C. If they’re equal, no jumps, otherwise we jump and get the bad message.
Now that we know how the target works, let’s make some corrections first:
X = P and Y = G and Z = Y
And let’s assign some variables:
- V1 = 0x408820 = G^M mod P
- Vt1 = 0x408824 = Y^R mod P
- Vt2 = 0x408828 = R^S mod P
- V2 = Vt1 * Vt2 mod P
So now we only need to solve the DLP Problem (Y=g^x mod p) and then we can find our pair C(R,S).
To solve DLP we can use one of the following websites:
http://www.alpertron.com.ar/DILOG.HTM (requires Java):
- Convert keys to base 10.
- Enter G in Base text.
- Y in Power text.
- P in Mod text.
- Click ‘Find discrete logarithm’ and wait.
http://magma.maths.usyd.edu.au/calc/: to use Magma Calculator we would fill the textbox with the following code and click ‘submit’:
p := 187513317350689708750027795311890398103;
K := GF(p);
g := K ! 81785581430583092797817457721148654627;
y := K ! 23968303030409235163863560552895394250;
x := Log(g, y);
Or we could just use figugegl’s DLPTool (which is what I’ve used):
I’ve got the following result:
X = 258A82FDE1F2E37D4FBC02BA3063FC4B
Let’s get a valid pair now. We’ll use the ELGAMALSiGNiT Tool again, so load it up and copy/paste each key in its place:
Click directly ‘CALCULATE Y=G^X (MOD P)’ you should get:
Now check MD5 as an output mode for M (if you recall it’s what’s used in the challenge).
Type something in M, I’ve typed ‘Jamal Chahir’.
Click ‘GENERATE’ to generate random K.
Let’s join these together: R+S
Now load up the challenge. Enter the name you typed in (M) and the joined pair R+S and click ‘Check’, you should be able to get the correct message:
Now you should be able to bypass softwares that use the ElGamal cryptosystem. The only two problems that you’ll encounter are: to identify the cryptographic library used by the software or not (depending on the programming languages), and the key size problem which must not be big (512bits, 1024bits). It could take a lot of time to solve DLP. I hope all is clear.
- Target: https://www.dropbox.com/s/4zj1goynpf791sr/CryptoChallenge2.rar?dl=0
- ELGAMALSiGNiT: https://www.dropbox.com/s/qpsz5247ad3m9jn/ELGAMALSiGNiT.rar?dl=0
- PEiD: http://www.softpedia.com/get/Programming/Packers-Crypters-Protectors/PEiD-updated.shtml
- IDA: https://www.hex-rays.com/products/ida
- RE-SIGS: https://tuts4you.com/download.php?view.3407
- GODUP: https://tuts4you.com/download.php?view.54
- DLP Tool: https://www.dropbox.com/s/qb5x8l1gwgdh8qn/dlptool.rar?dl=0